Opinion
Are Insurance Copayments Unethical?
Mammograms are recommended for all women over the age of 45 as a breast cancer screening tool. Some insurance and Medicare plans provide full coverage for these tests because they are deemed necessary and beneficial. Other plans apply co-pays to mammograms, and other similar medical interventions, despite the prevalent medical opinion that they are both necessary and beneficial to the health of the patient.
A large-scale study published in the New England Journal of Medicine found that patients who are required to pay $10 or more for a mammogram are significantly less likely to have the examination on a biannual basis when compared to individuals whose insurance plans provided complete coverage. This discrepancy was highest among lower income and less educated individuals, but was present across the board, including educated and financially stable patients.
Many writers and reporters have commented that co-payments for such important medical studies as mammograms are unethical, because they deter patients from having the exam regularly. I have no problem with providing free mammograms for women who legitimately cannot afford their co-pay. However, if someone who has the financial capability to pay $10 for a mammogram chooses not to do so, it is not the fault of the insurance company or the healthcare system, but of the patient.
Patients are responsible for eating healthy, exercising, getting enough sleep, and a myriad of other factors that doctors and insurers cannot control. They are also responsible for having good judgment. If you can afford the co-payment, but you just don’t like it, that is no excuse for failing to access medical care.
Healthcare providers bear the very important responsibility of educating patients about the importance of preventive measures such as annual mammography. Insurers have the task of making healthcare affordable and accessible. No one is responsible for making it free.
Reference
Trivedi, A.N., Rakowski, W., Ayanian, J.Z. (2008). Effect of Cost Sharing on Screening Mammography in Medicare Health Plans. New England Journal of Medicine, 358(4), 375-383. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMsa070929
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
- Religion - A "Natural" Phenomenon?
- Creating an Artificial Brain
- How Culture Shapes Our Mind and Brain
- Sex, Violence and The Male Warrior Hypothesis
- The Secret to Good Health – Listen to the Data
- If Herbal Medicine is Medicine, Shouldn't it be Treated as Such?
- Too Much Information?
- Swine Flu - A Lose-Lose Situation for Public Health Authorities
- Logging On for Psychotherapy
- The Neural Basis of the Self
- Income Inequality and Health Outcomes
- Post-Partum Psychosis - Rare but Real
- Worried Well on the Web
- Ginkgo Biloba Ineffective... Again
- The Evolution of Depression
- Is Your Doctor Happy or Burnt-Out?
- Journal Retracts Autism Research
- How Young is Too Young to Diagnose Depression?
- In Sickness and Mental Health
- Health Insurance for All - A Weighty Issue
- Speaking in Tongues – A Neural Snapshot
- Neuro Case 1 – Using Transcranial Doppler for Basilar Artery Occlusion
- Journal Retracts Autism Research
- Crossing the Line from Physician to Journalist
- Ginkgo Biloba Ineffective… Again
- The Smart Ones are Living Longer
- Too Much Information?
- Drugs and Pharmacology, Nineteenth Edition
- Coping with Trauma – Lessons from Resilient Individuals
- Worried Well on the Web
- Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Neuroscience Conferences for 2010
- One Puff Forward, Two Pounds Back
- Income Inequality and Health Outcomes
- Farewell 2009, Welcome 2010
- When the Drugs Don’t Work, or Just Make it Worse
- Is a Slim Santa Claus Coming to Town?
- Stimulants May Offer Protection in ADHD
- Sex, Violence and The Male Warrior Hypothesis
- Is Time on Your Side?
- Drugs and Pharmacology, Eighteenth Edition
- i do not know which Australlia you are talking abiuy. My impression about this c...
- The Institute of Natural Excellence has a new way to look at this and many other...
- My guessI expect that in their childhood...free flowing care free ...
- its the mind game when it comes to good healthy survival. better iq means better...
- the ability of brain to store information, regarding different languages while c...
- 12 children were taken as subjects for a very controversial research , the resu...
- Below is how and why the Swine flu was Genetically Engineered. For full version...
- Having worked with developmentally disabled persons for 17 years, I see many par...
- Great job. I've posted a link to here from the ...
- Yeah... I don't buy it. Know why? Because rotund Santa was around for many gener...
- For those unfamiliar with Dr. John Cannell's Vitamin D Theory of Autism see the...
- It is a pity that very little coverage of this issue names the journalist who is...
- I would like to see some research into what Ginkgo biloba does do instead of wha...
- It is easier for us to ignore the problem than really attack the problem, due to...
- I was going by Alan MacFarlane's description of Hunter Gatherer societies.( les...
- Javaid, where on earth do you get the idea that hunter-gatherers have little or ...
- This is my angle ..Hunter Gatherers have the lightest density footprint and ...
- yes , i really like it. isuggest everyone to be fit and healthy....
- Tribal groups - about as dispersed as population gets still have religion.I ...
- All this may be true for organized forms of religion. however, there is a facet ...
Sponsored Links
Diet and Health Supplements, Best vitamins supplements, Brain Fitness DVD, Home Care, Alcohol Rehab, Emergency Lighting, Online Criminal Justice Degrees, Tattoo, Health Insurance, Electronic Accessories , About Free Credit , Retractable Banner Stands , Surefit Slipcovers , Biotechnology , Breast Cancer and Adjuvant Therapy , Kenacomb Cream , Cystic Fibrosis Lung Treatment , Pancreas Cancer , Dallas health insurance , Arthritis Treatment , Pet Insurance , Lung Cancer Treatment , Frisco personal injury attorneys , Why Is Glucose Monitoring Important? , Edgepark Medical , Hydroxycut, Astrology compatibility.
Neuroscience & Neurology
February 07, 2010 | 3 Comments | By Dirk Hanson, MA
Speaking in Tongues – A Neural Snapshot
More In Neuroscience & Neurology
- Neuro Case 1 – Using Transcranial Doppler for Basilar Artery Occlusion
- Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Neuroscience Conferences for 2010
- Are Physicians Spending Too Much Time Diagnosing Patients?
- Two Wrongs Make a Right – Abnormal Brain Circuitry May Stop Abnormal Movement
- How Culture Shapes Our Mind and Brain
Neuroscience & Neurology
Opinion
February 01, 2010 | 0 Comments | By Jennifer Gibson, PharmD
Crossing the Line from Physician to Journalist
More In Opinion
- Sex, Violence and The Male Warrior Hypothesis
- Bruxism and the Brain
- Religion – A “Natural” Phenomenon?
- Natural Good, Chemical Bad – Right?
- Time for a Change – Gender Reassignment
Opinion
Psychiatry & Psychology
February 03, 2010 | 5 Comments | By Jennifer Gibson, PharmD
Journal Retracts Autism Research
More In Psychiatry & Psychology
- White Bears – The Paradox of Mental Suppression
- Sugar and Spice and Everything Nice?
- The Evolution of Depression
- Why So Serious About The Self?
- New Report on the Use of Antidepressants During Pregnancy


Leave a Reply