Pain Is No Matter for the Meditative Mind




Broken egg with bandaid

Remove your opinion about that which appears to give you pain and you stand painless.
— Marcus Aurelius

Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.
— Dalai Lama

The insight of Marcus Aurelius and the Dalai Lama about the nature of pain alludes to the practical knowledge that physical pain can be managed effectively through proper training and mental discipline, neatly summarized by the popular phrase “mind over matter.”

In the West, the notion of “mind over matter” has been circulating for centuries (at least since Aurelius and previous Stoic philosophers), yet it has been relatively recently that a technique that puts this insight into practice became the subject of serious scientific examination, namely mindfulness meditation. Mindfulness meditation achieves this effect by cultivating a sense of equanimity through objective observation of the internal processes of the body. Over the past decade, the science of mindfulness meditation has revealed a wide range of cognitive and emotional benefits conferred on practitioners including enhanced attention, lower pain sensitivity, and reduced emotional reactivity. The evidence for these benefits has also been supported by brain imaging studies in long-term meditators showing that change occurs at the physiological level.

To date, the majority of mindfulness meditation studies have been conducted in individuals with long-term intensive meditation experience. In a study published earlier this year in the Journal of Neuroscience, researchers at Wake Forest University explored the impact of mindfulness meditation on pain after only a few days of meditation training.

A group of 15 healthy volunteers took part in four 20-minute sessions of mindfulness meditation instruction where they were trained to maintain awareness on their own breathing while acknowledging and letting go of distraction.

The study evaluated the effect of mindfulness meditation in two dimensions: 1) how the volunteers reported pain intensity and unpleasantness, and 2) how brain activation patterns changed as measured by functional MRI. To assess the volunteer’s pain response, a small thermal simulator heated to around 120°F was applied to the back of the leg.

Comparing responses to the heat before and after meditation training, volunteers reported a 40% reduction in pain intensity and a 57% reduction in unpleasantness associated with the heat stimulus. Brain imaging indicated increased activation in areas associated with awareness of the pain sensation and a reduced activation in areas associated with the emotional response to pain perception.

Interestingly, a decoupling of two brain areas, the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and cingulate cortex, was observed. The prefrontal cortex is thought to control attention and other executive functions, whereas the cingulate cortex is associated with the emotional salience of a stimulus. The authors suggest that the beneficial effect of meditation may be due to a dissociation of the awareness of pain with the emotional evaluation of the pain attached to it. Accordingly, the meditators are aware of the pain sensation, but are not judging or focusing on the disturbing quality normally associated with the pain. Marcus Aurelius sums it up nicely,

If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself but to your own estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any moment.

As a way to better understand the meditation experience, think about the mental focus a top endurance athlete exhibits in competition. The conviction to overcome excruciating muscle aches and pains enables world class cyclists to complete the Tour de France (a 2000 mile race over 21 days at altitude) and long distance runners to finish marathons in around 2 hours (averaging less than 5 min per mile). Of course, great endurance athletes are not necessarily meditators, but they are individuals who have cultivated mental discipline with years of training in which they have come to appreciate the essence of “mind over matter.”

This study hints at the fascinating implication that one need not pursue the path of a monk, adopt an extreme stoic philosophy or even engage in an intensive meditation retreat to experience substantial health benefits. It’s possible that intensive meditation may offer additional rewards, yet this study shows that even short-term meditation training yields a meaningful reduction in the suffering associated with common, everyday pain.

The National Institutes of Health (NIH) estimates that 70 million Americans suffer from chronic pain with an economic burden of at least $100 billion in the United States. The low cost and low risk of mindfulness meditation make it particularly attractive for chronic pain sufferers, though the value extends to anyone looking for a boost in concentration and a reduction in suffering. In a way, we all have become conditioned to react to the distractions in our environments like a dog conditioned to the sound of a bell. And so couldn’t we all use a bit of the calm, quiet mind lying dormant beneath the sound of the iPhone, the Blackberry, and Pavlov’s bell ringing in our ear?

References

May Day Fund. A Call to Revolutionize Chronic Pain Care in America: An Opportunity in Health Care Reform. 2009.

Salomons TV, & Kucyi A (2011). Does Meditation Reduce Pain through a Unique Neural Mechanism? The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society for Neuroscience, 31 (36), 12705-7 PMID: 21900549

Zeidan F, Martucci KT, Kraft RA, Gordon NS, McHaffie JG, & Coghill RC (2011). Brain mechanisms supporting the modulation of pain by mindfulness meditation. The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society for Neuroscience, 31 (14), 5540-8 PMID: 21471390

Image via antoniomas / Shutterstock.

  • http://mindbodypainclinics.com/ Eric Reynolds

    Great article! Claims about meditation being a “cure” for chronic pain can be misleading and you have wisely avoided this. From what we have seen in our clinic, meditation is a great tool for altering patients’ relationship with pain. The experience of pain itself may also be changed (ie: pain reduced), but the emotional experience can definitely be affected by meditation. This is the essence of the quote you mention from Marcus Aurelius. One may or may not be able to alter the pain itself, but one can definitely alter one’s assessment of it, and thereby alter the experience.

  • Pingback: Ouch – another idea for pain management | Broken Brain – Brilliant Mind()

  • http://www.howtobesick.com Toni Bernhard

    I’ve been writing about using mindfulness techniques to help with chronic pain. They’re an extension of the mindfulness techniques in my book, “How to Be Sick: A Buddhist-Inspired Guide for the Chronically Ill and their Caregivers.”

    Here’s the link to my latest article. My next one will be on the body scan which is another mindfulness meditation technique to help with pain:

    I hope people find it helpful. Warmly, Toni

  • Pingback: Mental Projection! « Ralphie´s Portal()

  • Pingback: More about Pain and Meditation « Contemplative Mind in Life()

  • http://evolution-hypnotherapy.com Chris

    Mindfulness is a wonderful technique that helps the individual move their awareness and focus at will.
    When we focus on things such as pain, we are giving that focus our attention, and in effect, magnify it.
    I have only been using mindfulness over the last year and it can help with so many things, especially where the individual appears to be spending too much time focusing on the negative when they could and can at will, move their awareness onto something more helpful, beneficial or neutral.
    Best

    Chris

  • Charry

    Oh, I changed my mind again. I though it’s the body which makes the mind function well. But I think it is still true. Because when you are hungry you cannot think or focus on what you are thinking. But if it talks about reducing the pain, then I think “mind” wins.
    If “mind over matter” really matters, I think life can be healthier but not that easier. Nowadays, there are only very rare times when people can concentrate their mind on one thing.

  • lee du ploy

    Wherever you go, there you are.

    Conficuis with a little help from Kabit Zin.
    When I was a boy 70 years ago growing up in Africa , my grandfather used to say,”inspite of our intervention, the river of life will continue to flow,long after we have gone.
    I am interested in the sudden revilation that meditation calms the mind and thus the soul, which if we are to accept the current research is all about permitting the mind to be quiet.
    This ” mindblowing” fact was known for years before it was clinically proved and now accepted.
    Which begs the question” which other common sense fact is waitng to be discoved”?
    Meditation,mindfullnes and peace go” hand in hand” its a nobrainer.

    lee du ploy ( HOng Kong)

  • Harley

    Great article. I have thought that there could be a better way than just taking pain pills. Meditation might be the answer. I have also heard of P-STIM which helps with pain, and isn’t a pain pill too.

  • http://www.doctorshealthpress.com/ Jacob edward

    This characteristic is often criticized as indicating that the theorizing is doing no work, and that any true theory has to offer pain with the gain.

    For more information please visit:

Stephen Dougherty, MS

Stephen Dougherty, MS, is a freelance science and medical writer with experience developing medical education materials and multimedia learning applications. He has worked for several years as a researcher in cell biology and neurobiology and holds a Masters of Science in Behavioral Neuroscience.
See All Posts By The Author

Do not miss out ever again. Subscribe to get our newsletter delivered to your inbox a few times a month.