Articles & Studies

Domestic Violence: Call for Primary Care Screening and Gender Issues – Part I

April 19, 2008 | By Robert Yourell, MA | Share, Save, and Bookmark | 4 Comments

Articles_Studies.jpgIn this article, and some to follow, I will provide a glimpse into controversies and progress in the field of domestic violence (DV). Issues of mental illness, cognitive disabilities, personality disorders, unemployment, poverty, gender, politics, the legal system, and education loom large in DV, calling for a biopsychosocial perspective. What better place than Brain Blogger for a look at the subject? Because it is such a tremendously large and complicated topic, I will write about it through different lenses.

I am not an expert in DV, but I have had my share of exposure in my work with federal probation and pre-trial, in chemical dependence, in family therapy, and in employee assistance programs. The way I put together this snapshot, was by monitoring a major discussion list of experts and practitioners in the field of DV, and doing a survey of DV-related research, particularly that concerned with mental health issues.

RelationshipI’ll start with a very good reason for primary care providers to screen for DV, and an initial look at gender issues.

The number of women being arrested for DV is increasing. They constitute one-fifth of these arrests. There is concern, though, as to how many of them are women who were fighting back. The concern is amplified by the fact that some batterers are able to manipulate the police and the courts. According to authors such as Jackie Campbell, the batterer who succeeds with such manipulation rebound even bolder with a victim less likely to call for help; the danger is greater.

However, statistics showing that over half of violence in relationships comes from women (not danger or physical harm, there’s a difference) could lead one to say that this might be playing out as much to harm men as it does women, especially since the bias is generally against men, who are presumed to be the perpetrators. An expression of this bias developed in clinical thinking in the form of the idea of learned helplessness, in which, through abusive manipulation, women were believed to become unable to effectively defend themselves through escape, self-advocacy, or other means. Research has not supported the idea that this characterizes most women who experience DV. When police encounter women who are fighting with their men, and who are drunk and surly, they are not prepared very well to respond by this kind of bias.

In any case, the research and advocacy on DV calls for routine screening for DV in primary care settings, including maternity settings. The motive for this is to get early intervention, which will prevent violence, save lives, and get help before the DV dynamic becomes more ingrained. According to Jackie Campbell, nearly half of women killed by their partner are seen in primary care settings prior to their deaths, but only 4% of them were in shelters.

Related Articles


4 Comments/Trackbacks

You can follow any responses to this article through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Megan from Imaginif
April 19, 2008 | Permalink

I welcome screening and early intervention.
Domestic Violence is a child protection issue and if child protection is every body’s business then so it preventing and protecting from domestic violence.

Looking forward to the series.

Mike Calahan
April 14, 2009 | Permalink

You may be interested in our recent publication “Hidden Costs in Healthcare: The Economic Impact of Violence and Abuse now available on our website.

Trackbacks


Leave a Reply

Subscribe Without Commenting

Saturday, July 4, 2009

Brain Blogger's Historical Brain Illustrations

Charles Bell: Course of the Nerves - Neck and Thorax, c. 19th centuryBartolomeo Eustachi: Peripheral Nervous System, c. 1722Bartolomeo Eustachi: Brain and Spine Anatomy, c. 1722Ambroise Pare, Siamese twins illustrated, c. unknownHow to prepare the skull for surgery, brain unexposed, c. 16th centuryHow to prepare the skull for surgery, brain exposed, c. 16th centuryThomas Bartholin: Transected Head Anatomy, c. 1673Antonio Scarpa: Anatomy of Olfaction (Smell), c. 1779Charles Bell: Anatomy of the Brain, c. 1802

Sponsored Links

Neuroscience & Neurology

June 09, 2009 | 3 Comments | By Sajid Surve, DO

What is Proprioception?

More In Neuroscience & Neurology


Neuroscience & Neurology

Opinion

June 21, 2009 | 6 Comments | By T. A. McNamee, MD

Time for a Change – Gender Reassignment

More In Opinion


Opinion

Psychiatry & Psychology

July 03, 2009 | 2 Comments | By Dirk Hanson, MA

Why Do Schizophrenics Smoke Cigarettes?

More In Psychiatry & Psychology