
Difficulties Teaching Mental Health in Med School: We Need More Answers!
From our previous discussion, Scott (a commentator) proposed a very interesting basis for the disparity of mental health management in contemporary health care: lack of medical training on the subject. Typically, mental health disorders are covered in a short course in the classroom training of medical students. Then, in the hospital, medical students learn clinical aspects of mental health in psychiatry and other rotations (e.g., emergency medicine). Also, general pharmacology for medical students covers anti-psychotics, antidepressants, and anxiolytics (drugs to relieve anxiety) generally across a few lessons. Given the high prevalence of mental illness, certainly many topics in medicine are disproportionately lectured.
It is true, however, that many aspects of mental disorders are uncertain or simply unknown. Academicians in medicine find it difficult to teach these disorders in terms of pathogenesis (the series of disturbances that lead to the given disorder). For instance, what pathological specimens can be shown from a microscope demonstration to illustrate schizophrenia? What lab tests can a clinician order to positively diagnose a bipolar disorder? To date, none! Therefore, it is quite easy to give a list of symptoms, criteria for diagnosis, and medical treatment options, since these are readily available and largely undisputed in the scientific community.
Most will agree that mental health does not gain “the same credibility as heart diseases or cancer” as Scott suggests. It will remain this way until we (1) uncover mechanisms and pathways for the development of schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and the plethora of other DSM diagnoses and (2) integrate imaging and biochemical markers. [See my article on schizophrenia proteomics for a detailed discussion on the issue, from the technological and clinical implications to ethical considerations.]
5 Responses
[...] Brain Blogger Shaheen’s assertion that the only way to understand mental health issues is through the medicalization and organic markers for mental disorders and tests derived from such mark…. Psychology and psychiatry have established a very deep, rich knowledgebase of mental disorders and [...]
All Things Medical April Edition…
All Things Medical  April Edition Carnival is up.
……
Leave a Reply
Popular Posts
- Mind Games - Science's Attempts at Thought Control
- The Science of Stuttering
- Risks of Personalized Medicine
- Intelligence - Are You Holding Back Your Brain?
- Is Grief a Mental Illness?
- The Brain's Buying Power
- The Cost of a Good Night's Sleep
- Inside Your Brain on Holiday
- Risk Factors for Recurrence of Depression
- Salvia Divinorum - DEA Control over Magic in the Mint
Future Posts
Latest Posts
- A Gateway to Weight Loss?
- Intelligence – Do You Need it to be Successful?
- A Trip for Terminal Patients
- Memory Ain’t What It Used to Be – And That’s Good for Psychotherapy
- The Science of Stuttering
- Are Your Friends Making You Fat?
- Beer – The Smarter Drink
- Macroeconomics and Suicide
- From Nymphomania to Hypersexuality
- Commitment – It’s the new Love
Comments
- brucemclaren: Our company employees are well
- brucemclaren: Waar gewerkt wordt, kunnen arb
- Ryan: Great post! I agree with the p
- : I have used heroin for 20 year
- Lino Baine: I am not aware that people wit
- Lulu Jones: Hmm....this is interesting. I
- Robert A. Yourell, MA: Hi Stephanie...OR they tried a
- Stephnie: Based on the facts in the arti
- Sammy: I was a test subject for one o
- Veronica Pamoukaghlian, MA: Thank you for your insightful
- Richard Kensinger, MSW: I agree w/ Howard Gardner's pe
- Melbzi: Muso's and smoked pot.I q









Absolutely TRUE!
I thought most docs just married social workers or psychologists so they could consult over dinner and figure out what the heck they were dealing with that day in the office. This would follow thinking Hmm, maybe medication isn’t the ONLY solution to this problem, and a look at the brain won’t help the kid’s grades, stop her from cheating, etc. etc.
Here’s my answer. Why don’t ridiculously young men and women with no experience in life beyond the classroom, consult a MOTHER or a FATHER? The “mechanisms and pathways” as you refer to it are unique to every person, family and gestational environment. Mental illness is not an academic exercise. See my blog post on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, posted Sept. 2.