Opinion
Difficulties Teaching Mental Health in Med School: We Need More Answers!
From our previous discussion, Scott (a commentator) proposed a very interesting basis for the disparity of mental health management in contemporary health care: lack of medical training on the subject. Typically, mental health disorders are covered in a short course in the classroom training of medical students. Then, in the hospital, medical students learn clinical aspects of mental health in psychiatry and other rotations (e.g., emergency medicine). Also, general pharmacology for medical students covers anti-psychotics, antidepressants, and anxiolytics (drugs to relieve anxiety) generally across a few lessons. Given the high prevalence of mental illness, certainly many topics in medicine are disproportionately lectured.
It is true, however, that many aspects of mental disorders are uncertain or simply unknown. Academicians in medicine find it difficult to teach these disorders in terms of pathogenesis (the series of disturbances that lead to the given disorder). For instance, what pathological specimens can be shown from a microscope demonstration to illustrate schizophrenia? What lab tests can a clinician order to positively diagnose a bipolar disorder? To date, none! Therefore, it is quite easy to give a list of symptoms, criteria for diagnosis, and medical treatment options, since these are readily available and largely undisputed in the scientific community.
Most will agree that mental health does not gain “the same credibility as heart diseases or cancer” as Scott suggests. It will remain this way until we (1) uncover mechanisms and pathways for the development of schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and the plethora of other DSM diagnoses and (2) integrate imaging and biochemical markers. [See my article on schizophrenia proteomics for a detailed discussion on the issue, from the technological and clinical implications to ethical considerations.]
5 Comments/Trackbacks
I thought most docs just married social workers or psychologists so they could consult over dinner and figure out what the heck they were dealing with that day in the office. This would follow thinking Hmm, maybe medication isn’t the ONLY solution to this problem, and a look at the brain won’t help the kid’s grades, stop her from cheating, etc. etc.
Here’s my answer. Why don’t ridiculously young men and women with no experience in life beyond the classroom, consult a MOTHER or a FATHER? The “mechanisms and pathways” as you refer to it are unique to every person, family and gestational environment. Mental illness is not an academic exercise. See my blog post on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, posted Sept. 2.
Trackbacks
- Mar 29, 2007 | I’m Not Just a Biochemical or Gene, I’m a Human Being - World of Psychology
- Apr 25, 2007 | RDoctor Medical
Leave a Reply
Monday, March 22, 2010
- Religion - A "Natural" Phenomenon?
- Psychotropics and Youth, Part 1 - The Five Myths
- How Culture Shapes Our Mind and Brain
- Sex, Violence and The Male Warrior Hypothesis
- The Secret to Good Health – Listen to the Data
- If Herbal Medicine is Medicine, Shouldn't it be Treated as Such?
- Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Neuroscience Conferences for 2010
- Too Much Information?
- "I Feel Your Pain" - The Neural Basis of Empathy
- Income Inequality and Health Outcomes
- The Evolution of Depression
- Journal Retracts Autism Research
- Speaking in Tongues - A Neural Snapshot
- Why Some Human Brains Become Leaders, While Others Followers?
- Post-Partum Psychosis - Rare but Real
- Is Your Doctor Happy or Burnt-Out?
- Worried Well on the Web
- Ginkgo Biloba Ineffective... Again
- Psychotropics and Youth, Part 2 - The Solutions
- Postoperative Cognitive Dysfunction
- Empathy – How Much is Too Much?
- Let the Matches Begin!
- My Nephew and his Brain, Part 4 – Their Life Today
- My Nephew and his Brain, Part 3 – Try to Work Out their Troubles
- My Nephew and his Brain, Part 2 – Revealed to be Complicated
- My Nephew and his Brain, Part 1 – Introduction
- Deep Brain Stimulation – A New Frontier in Psychiatry
- Psychotropics and Youth, Part 3 – Equip Teachers with Prescription Pads?
- Why Some Human Brains Become Leaders, While Others Followers?
- Brain Blogger Finalist for Two 2010 Research Blogging Awards in Neuroscience and Psychology
- Tall Tales of Diabetic Amputations
- Psychotropics and Youth, Part 2 – The Solutions
- Brain Blogging, Forty-Ninth Edition
- How Your Brain Groups Words
- The Child Brain and the Playing Teacher
- You Have a Right to Choose if we Agree
- Measuring Quality in Primary Care
- Matchmaker, Matchmaker Make Me A Match – The NRMP Main Residency Match
- Psychotropics and Youth, Part 1 – The Five Myths
- When It Comes to Aging, Size Matters
- i agree you dianne...
- Often, patients report persistent physical symptoms, but no somatic ...
- Great help, understood who is a LEADER & a FOLLOWER. Is there a category wh...
- Don't agree, to my opinion empathy is not easily learned, it's a quality not eve...
- Thanks, got the meaning of INTELLIGENCE/IQ....
- I'm a 54 yrs old woman .i was working for a retail company for 5 yrs ,my husbend...
- Thanks so much for sharing. My daughter began having seizures when she was 17. S...
- yea ur right lol lughter the best medicine i cnt do without it in a day!!!!!!!!!...
- Very touching story. My heart goes out to your family. Seizures are tough. And ...
- Thank you for sharing your nephew's story. So hard on those who love him, but I...
- Congratulations to all who've matched! Although the results of NRMP Main Residen...
- It's been almost 25 years since my son suffered a TBI in an accident. He was onl...
- I tend to agree with the teachers.But a teacher can only keep a record about the...
- Very interesting article, the 5th paragraph gets a little biased...but I still e...
- Dear Dan,There is certainly much clinical interest in this field. ClinicalTr...
- I recently commented on a sciencedaily.com article reporting success with TRD an...
- I have family members who are teachers. After sharing this article with them, th...
- It is great that people are challenging the use of this medication. As, a societ...
- I agree with the stand of the teachers and their children's that more than half ...
- I think that there’s also a social aspect to it. If you grow up in an area where...
Sponsored Links
Brain Fitness DVD, Home Care, Alcohol Rehab, Emergency Lighting, Online Criminal Justice Degrees, Tattoo, Diet and Health Supplements, Best vitamins supplements, Health Insurance, Wireless Accessories , Rollup Banner Stands , Biotherapeutic Product Information , Breast Cancer , Buy Baytril , Lung Health , Erlotinib , Dallas health insurance , Knee Pain Treatment , Long Term Disability Insurance , Lung Cancer Treatment , immigration attorney Plano , What Are The Symptoms Of Mitral Valve Prolapse Condition? , Edgepark Medical , Mattress , Hydroxycut, Astrology compatibility.
Neuroscience & Neurology
March 06, 2010 | 8 Comments | By Simi Agarwal, DDS
Why Some Human Brains Become Leaders, While Others Followers?
More In Neuroscience & Neurology
- How Your Brain Groups Words
- The Child Brain and the Playing Teacher
- “I Feel Your Pain” – The Neural Basis of Empathy
- Speaking in Tongues – A Neural Snapshot
- Neuro Case 1 – Using Transcranial Doppler for Basilar Artery Occlusion
Neuroscience & Neurology
Opinion
February 01, 2010 | 1 Comment | By Jennifer Gibson, PharmD
Crossing the Line from Physician to Journalist
More In Opinion
- Sex, Violence and The Male Warrior Hypothesis
- Bruxism and the Brain
- Religion – A “Natural” Phenomenon?
- Natural Good, Chemical Bad – Right?
- Time for a Change – Gender Reassignment
Opinion
Psychiatry & Psychology
March 21, 2010 | 1 Comment | By Jennifer Gibson, PharmD
Empathy – How Much is Too Much?
More In Psychiatry & Psychology
- Deep Brain Stimulation – A New Frontier in Psychiatry
- Psychotropics and Youth, Part 2 – The Solutions
- Psychotropics and Youth, Part 1 – The Five Myths
- Journal Retracts Autism Research
- White Bears – The Paradox of Mental Suppression


Absolutely TRUE!