Health & Healthcare
Concierge Medicine - The Future or the Past?
The current US healthcare system is broken. Few would argue this point. Rising costs, decreasing reimbursements, more lawsuits, insurance hikes, and an aging population are just some of the difficulties that face both physicians and patients today, and the situation doesn’t seem to be improving.
One of the other major problems is the shortage of time. In order to make ends meet, doctors are being forced to see more and more patients in the same amount of time. For many physicians, what used to be an hour for new patients and half hour for established patients has been shrunk down to 20 minutes for a new patient and 10 minutes for an established one.
How could quality care possibly be carried out in such little time?
The recent advancements in medical technology and preventative medicine alone would take hours to adequately explain to a patient. Needless to say, accomplishing this feat is essentially impossible.
As a solution to this problem, an increasing number of physicians are turning to something known as “concierge medicine,” or “boutique medicine.” Under this system, patients are required to pay a yearly fee to the physician above and beyond the cost of their healthcare, which can range from $1,000 to $20,000. In return for this fee, they are granted a much higher level of access to their physician than one would expect. Doctors who participate in concierge medicine spend an hour with their patients on visits. They give out their personal cell phone numbers to be reached at all times. Many make house calls at no additional fee. Physicians guarantee that if you are sick and need to be seen, you can do so within 2 hours. Those long waits in the doctor’s office? Gone. Concierge physicians guarantee no wait in the waiting room.
Does this arrangement sound enticing to you? What would you do if you could spend an hour with your doctor on a visit, going through each of your problems in detail and really discussing the issues surrounding it? What if your doctor took the time to get a complete family history and perform all the latest cutting edge screening tools to assess your future risk for disease? Quality of care under this system would almost necessarily improve.
Of course, controversy stems from the fact that patients with lower income would likely not be able to afford these services. Also, if doctors are seeing fewer patients then we would need more of them to meet the demand. The system isn’t perfect by any means, but it’s a start in the right direction while we wait patiently for tangible universal healthcare. What do you think?
Related Articles
3 Comments
It is an interesting alternative or supplement to the idea of universal health care. I think that this is a logical extension of market segmentation, but I think when applied to health-care (and not airline tickets) it could be viewed as elitist. It’s an interesting idea, though, and worth a shot.
I use concierge medicine, as I have a quite rare, complex genetic condition. I’ve found that it is an invaluable investment for my situation.
I think the elitist criticism is a real, serious concern. I would love to see some of the management companies taking the initiative to do their part to mitigate this issue. For instance, my doctor has limited his practice to 600 patients. I’d be willing to consider switching companies if there was one that limited the practice to 500 concierge patients and 100 patients who were unable to afford the service.
Additionally, I believe that whatever the ultimate outcome, the emphasis being put on healthcare and the growing issues involved will have a positive impact on the current circumstances.
Leave a Reply
Thursday, January 8, 2009
- The Anti-Psychiatry Movement
- Vaccines - A Two-Edged Sword
- Should Doctors Have Guns?
- Extremist Muslim Doctors Do More Than Heal
- God And Religion: Is It All In Our Heads?
- Woman Comparable to Men in Domestic Violence: Stereotypes and their Consequences
- The Bipolar Trend
- Anti-Smoking Campaign Doesn't Mess Around
- The Science of Brain Freeze
- Are You Vegetarian? How Do You Get Enough Protein?
- The Implications of Implanted Chips
- Is War A Psychosis?
- The Biopsychosocial Model of Health & Illness
- Meditation for Troubled Minds: Can the Mind Heal the Mind?
- Unhinging from Theory: Autism and Opinions
- Mind-Body: We Want Evidence, Don't We?
- Encephalon, Thirty-Third Edition
- Acknowledging Vaccination Concerns
- Health Care and Politics II - The Democrats
- Usually It's Cheaper to Pay Than to Go To Court
- Deep Brain Stimulation for Pleasure
- Recent Drug Warnings About Suicide
- Sleeping on the Job - A Program Director’s Take on IOM Recommendations
- Work and Mental Health
- Why a Smartphone is a Dumb Idea
- Sometimes It’s Good to Be Cold - Therapeutic Hypothermia
- Recognizing the Man in the Mirror
- Brain Blogging, Forty-Second Edition
- Happiness is Contagious, If Not For a Fleeting Moment
- Look Me in the Eyes - From Eye Contact to “Fear Blindness”
- The Doctor Can’t See You Right Now, He’s Napping
- Suicide Rates Could Rise
- Gingko Study Proves Nothing
- Exercise to Keep Your Brain Healthy and Increase Cerebral Blood Flow
- Personal Health Records and Mental Health
- New Option for the Management of Acute Pain
- Depression and the Risk for Cardiovascular Events
- Beating the Biological Clock - Clinical Trials of Tasimelteon
- Ginkgo Biloba Ineffective for Preventing Dementia
- A Special Thanks - Remembering a Man Who Remembered No One
- Your source is outdated, Jennifer. That study was done in 2000. There are more...
- The dilemma you point out is an important one. SSRIs will lead some people to be...
- Chantix needs the suicide warning, and behavior changes warning.. It is also imp...
- As someone who has survived the suicide of a family member who was prescribed an...
- Hi Kas,
Yes, we surely have been plagiarized once again by detoxinabox.com. Fin...
- ...
- Hi Simes,
Thanks for bringing this to my attention. These thieves...
- Do you know you've been plagiarised at www.detoxinabox.com/blog/which-came-first...
- I found this an excellent post on a very professional blog, and have selected it...
- As a psychologist somewhat familiar with the sleep deprivation research, it stri...
- We can spread happiness by simply smiling at others. We make ourselves happy in ...
- The 6 months I was unemployed (having had a stressful- but not anxiety inducing-...
- Detractors can argue all they want. My now 15 year old was 4 months old and cryi...
- USC doctor Gerald Loeb and Jonathan Kellerman are guilty of implanting un-consen...
- try relaxation techniques. yoga, massage....anything. ^_^...
- I think we all have a place in society for helping people with mood disorders an...
- I've always had a hard time separating my work life from my home life. It took ...
- I have been on the Donor 's list for 17 years, never got a call. But I would sti...
- Very nice work. Thanks......
- Good Day,
I have been diagnosed with Essential Tremor and would like to recei...
Brain Blogger's Historical Brain Illustrations









Sponsored Links
Neuroscience & Neurology
January 08, 2009 | 0 Comments | By Sajid Surve, DO
Deep Brain Stimulation for Pleasure
More In Neuroscience & Neurology
- Look Me in the Eyes - From Eye Contact to “Fear Blindness”
- Are Boys Really More Hard-Wired for Math than Girls?
- School Bullies - Is the Amygdala to Blame?
- Reversing the Irreversible - Neuromotor Prostheses for Spinal Cord Injury
- Electrical Brain Stimulation Improves Hand Motor Skills
Neuroscience & Neurology
Opinion
December 31, 2008 | 1 Comment | By Sajid Surve, DO
Why a Smartphone is a Dumb Idea
More In Opinion
- Suicide Rates Could Rise
- The Gift of Life - Part 3
- China’s Tainted Reputation
- HIPAA Doesn’t Exist For Doctors
- Some Funny Stories From the Trenches
Opinion
Psychiatry & Psychology
January 06, 2009 | 3 Comments | By Joseph Kim, MD, MPH
Recent Drug Warnings About Suicide
More In Psychiatry & Psychology
- Work and Mental Health
- Recognizing the Man in the Mirror
- Psychiatric Conditions and Alcohol Abuse in the College-Aged
- Conditioned Response - An Alternative to Antidepressant Drugs?
- Pulling Your Hair Out - Complexities of Trichotillomania


Dr. Surve is correct about the benefits of concierge medicine - benefits experienced by both the patient and the doctor. I opened one of the first concierge practices in this country 8 years ago. I’ve just written the first book to be published on the subject, “Concierge Medicine, A New System to Get the Best Healthcare” (Greenwood/Praeger, May 2008). Though there are controversies, concierge medicine is now available for the middle class and is quite affordable in many areas. Most of the arguments against concierge medicine fall apart under scrutiny. I have an entire chapter in my book devoted to this issue.
Concierge medicine is driven by patient dissatisfaction over our present fast-food medical model of HMOs, PPOs and a failing Medicare system. Patients love the time they have with their concierge doctors. Doctors love having the time to do what they were trained to do. Unless primary care medicine becomes more attractive to young doctors, by implementing models such as concierge medicine, no one will opt for a career in internal medicine, family practice or pediatrics and the shortage of primary care doctors will only worsen.
Steven D. Knope, M.D.