Health & Healthcare
Doctors Going “Non-Par” - A New Trend in Medicine
For those of you that don’t know, there is a new trend in medicine these days — it’s called going “Non-Par.” Non-Par simply means “Non-Participating.” When a physician goes Non-Par, it means that he or she is no longer participating in certain insurance reimbursement schemes. What this means is that a physician will no longer accept insurance or even Medicare. I know that sounds crazy, but it is happening.
Physicians are frustrated with the payment mechanism in the United States. When you bill out $250 for an office visit, the insurance pays you $60. In the old days, the insurance companies paid out a lot. The lowest payer was Medicare. However, as the elderly populations has swelled, Medicare has dropped reimbursements to all-time lows. Insurance companies have gotten smart and decided to match Medicare payments. Why should they pay more for a service that Medicare pays less for?
Physicians, being the poor businesspeople we are, didn’t balk but kept receiving the lower payments. It has gotten so bad that in most major cities such as San Francisco or New York, physicians cannot afford to make a living there. The ones that do are the ones that take cash for things such as Plastic Surgery, Dermatology and Skin Care.
Now there is a backlash in some areas. Doctors are fed up. They need to see a ton more of patients in order to pay for overhead. They are working like dogs and running hard in the rat race. Some of simply backed out and informed their patients that they can only see patients who can pay cash or can pay the difference of what insurance does not cover. For example, if their surgery costs $4,000 and the insurance can only pay $2,000, the doctor asks that the patient pay the $2,000 difference.
Some are saying that this is unethical. Others are saying that this is simply doctors fighting back. They are not trying to gouge their patients — they are simply trying to make a living.
It’s tough to say whether this is a fad or the start of a trend. Going Non-Par is not sustainable for generalists because there are simply other doctors that patients will go to see. Many specialists cannot do it either because there are too many specialists. But if you go out to a rural area, you’ll find that a specialist can call the shots and go Non-Par.
From a patient’s perspective this is bad. It limits choices of care. However, some could argue that going non-par separates those doctors that want to care for patients regardless of patient socioeconomic status, versus those doctors that only want to treat high end paying patients.
Related Articles
2 Comments
Jennifer
Emmanuel L.R.Diaz,MD.
I totally agree with these article. As I was begining my practice as a doctor here in the Philippines I have worked with a HMO which pays me by the hour to see patients. I also get paid for procedures that I do on the patient. But to be honest I get paid for services after a month and payment is only aorund 30-40% of what I would charge if I did the procedures in my own clinic. A lot of doctors here have gone none par which is much better thing to do since doctors who do co-pay are given the silent disaffiliation treatment. silent disaffiliation means that doctors who charge extra are not referred any patients but are still considered as affiliates of the HMO. I agree that doctors are really bad business people primarily because we were not trained to be business people. I dont mind seeing 100 people a day but if 20-25 of them were paying and the rest were either “gratis” or insurance were would that leave me. I would most likely just be breakeven at the end of the month.
In order to make insurance pay more i think that the various medical societies should work as a team in demanding fair and adequate payment. This is currently being done in the Philippines when the Society of neurologist requested all fellows not to accept referrrals from HMO’s until a reasonable agreement regarding payments can be achieved. Sanctions of course were given to fellows who did not follow the societies request. At present both the society and the HMO are sitting down and discussing agreeable payment schemes for both parties. Most of the neurologist now are making good money (i guess) since most of their patient are paying patients and they get the payments on time.
Leave a Reply
Friday, August 8, 2008
- The Anti-Psychiatry Movement
- Vaccines - A Two-Edged Sword
- Should Doctors Have Guns?
- Extremist Muslim Doctors Do More Than Heal
- Woman Comparable to Men in Domestic Violence: Stereotypes and their Consequences
- The Bipolar Trend
- The Implications of Implanted Chips
- Anti-Smoking Campaign Doesn't Mess Around
- The Biopsychosocial Model of Health & Illness
- Unhinging from Theory: Autism and Opinions
- The Science of Brain Freeze
- Encephalon, Thirty-Third Edition
- Meditation for Troubled Minds: Can the Mind Heal the Mind?
- God And Religion: Is It All In Our Heads?
- Mind-Body: We Want Evidence, Don't We?
- Usually It's Cheaper to Pay Than to Go To Court
- Acknowledging Vaccination Concerns
- Integrating Schizophrenia Management
- Is War A Psychosis?
- Rabies Virus Helps Deliver Drugs into the Brain
- Public Health Needs a Shot in the Arm
- Medical Students Can Make A Difference
- What Makes A Good Doctor? - A Patient’s Perspective
- Can this Economic Downturn Lead to Better Psychosocial Health?
- Fall Prevention - Who is Ultimately Responsible?
- Anti-Epileptic Drugs and the Risk of Suicide
- Real Life Medicine in Nepal - The Headache Phenomenon
- The Trans Fat Ban - Is High-Fructose Corn Syrup Next?
- The Lighter Side of Medicine
- Viruses Cause Cancer?
- There Is No Sham In Acupuncture
- Finding New Ways to Treat Depression
- Medicine and the Law - Part 5: Abandonment
- Brain Blogging, Thirty-Seventh Edition
- Why Your City Planner Is Making You Fat
- A Bad Mix - Cell Phones and Children?
- Emergency Rooms - Overcrowded and Understaffed
- Which Came First - Depression or Diabetes?
- A Fatal Lack of Data
- When Age Is Just A Number
- Your title should be the "Pharmaceuticals Industry is looking to new ways to pr...
- Thanks for the great information, especially about how postpartum depression is ...
- [...]Over at Brain Blogger, What Makes A Good Doctor? - A Patient’s Perspective,...
- I do believe that the DSM has been used as a replacement for causes and effects....
- A shocking video. And I see that it has sparked a lively debate. I believe that ...
- As a patient, I agree with your list except I would add another.
Tr...
- At first good bedside manners are the most important attributes for a physician....
- Know that compassion pushes away depression. Sometimes it is necessary to brake ...
- The problem with HFCS is that, because it is utilized differently in the body, i...
- I believe as long as a physician is capable to make appropriate decisions, and i...
- It is my understand that the final rule from CMS includes 12 events for no-pay a...
- Addictive potential? Marijuana has no addictive potential. Don't be taken in by ...
- Yay! Interesting......
- Basically we all need to take more control of our lives. There are some rather ...
- Thanks for the post...
- I am not opposed to biometric technology. My own hospital requires multiple pass...
- Thanks for ur article ..i read it and love it.....very touchy...hope these so c...
- I was under the impression that the latest research found high-fructose corn syr...
- Greetings from Japan.
Yes, Kampo is a "Japanese invention" that has A LOT OF go...
- I agree with Kristen, who wrote so well.
Being a German acupuncturist with 25 y...
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
Neuroscience & Neurology
July 21, 2008 | 2 Comments | By RD, MD
When Age Is Just A Number
More In Neuroscience & Neurology
- Virtual Reality - New Steps in Stroke Rehabilitation
- The Science of Brain Freeze
- Blood Glucose and the Brain: Sugar and Short-Term Memory
- New Technology for Intracranial Aneurysms
- Using Infrared Light to Diagnosis Alzheimer’s
Neuroscience & Neurology
Opinion
August 07, 2008 | 0 Comments | By JC, MD
Medical Students Can Make A Difference
More In Opinion
- Can this Economic Downturn Lead to Better Psychosocial Health?
- Real Life Medicine in Nepal - The Headache Phenomenon
- Why Your City Planner Is Making You Fat
- A Fatal Lack of Data
- Breaking News - Exercise is Good for You!
Opinion
Psychiatry & Psychology
July 28, 2008 | 4 Comments | By J. R. White
Finding New Ways to Treat Depression
More In Psychiatry & Psychology
- Dying To Be A Good Mom - Eating Disorders In Pregnancy
- The State of Mental Healthcare in Prison
- Treating Psychiatric Disorders - Something Smells Fishy
- Should Patients with Schizophrenia Receive Free Medication?
- Does Having ADHD Mean Doing Poorly in School?















My gynecologist of many years did that recently. I don’t have a problem with it. He bills my insurance company as a courtesy and applies any payments to my account, but I’m responsible. The other day he avoided doing a test to save me money, because he felt it wasn’t necessary. Would he have done it if Blue Cross was paying? Not sure…