Law & Politics
The Huckabee Diet: A Flawed Model of Health Advocacy
Mike Huckabee, ex-Governor of Arkansas, might not be a Universal Healthcare advocate, but his stance on tackling the obesity epidemic might need closer scrutiny than many of the professional nutrition programs out there. Beyond the rhetoric of his advocacy of a slimmer America, there is one important truth - current healthcare insurance systems indirectly reward ‘obesity’ through payouts rather than personal initiatives to stay fit. As the Governor of Arkansas he led the battle against obesity for the state at a political level, calling for changes in insurance legislation.
His well-publicized battle against film-maker Michael Moore, unfortunately, is pitched at a more personal level after the release of Sicko in 2007:
“Frankly, Michael Moore is an example of why the healthcare system costs so much in this country. He is clearly one of the reasons why we have a very expensive system. I know that from my own personal experience.”
After being diagnosed with diabetes, Huckabee lost more than 110 pounds and took up running avidly, and assumed moral legitimacy for being an advocate against obesity. In his 2005 book Quit Digging your Grave with a Knife and Fork, he calls for a twelve-pronged attack on some of our unhealthy habits and lifestyle choices: “making excuses”, “sitting on the couch”, “ignoring signals from the body”, “listening to destructive criticism”, “whining”, “expecting immediate success”, “making exceptions”, “storing provisions for failure”, “fueling with contaminated food”, “allowing food to be a reward” and “neglecting your spiritual health”. Sadly there is nothing revolutionary here - most weight loss experts insist upon a behavioral approach to tackle the epidemic, but Huckabee puts the blame squarely on the individual. “If you are fat, you are guzzling resources and its completely your fault”, seems to be his message,”If I can lose weight, so can you”.
But Huckabee’s solution and dieting plan is simplistic considering the overtly complex roots of obesity - a true modern epidemic. Coming from a politician, and not a personal dietitian, we would have expected that he would have called for state-sponsored nutritional re-education and public health preventional intervention. Instead his call for a social justice - “the thin should not pay for the fat”, is unlikely to solve the problem in a society that massively overproduces and merchandises food way beyond its own nutritional requirements. Particularly, when he himself, once upon a time was guilty of the same blame that he accuses others with.
Related Articles
3 Comments
Charles
Trackbacks
- Feb 15, 2008 | The Skinny On January » Blog Archive » Carnival of Holistic Nutrition - February 15, 2008
- Feb 16, 2008 | Weight Master
Leave a Reply
Saturday, July 5, 2008
- The Anti-Psychiatry Movement
- Vaccines - A Two-Edged Sword
- Should Doctors Have Guns?
- Woman Comparable to Men in Domestic Violence: Stereotypes and their Consequences
- Extremist Muslim Doctors Do More Than Heal
- The Bipolar Trend
- The Biopsychosocial Model of Health & Illness
- Unhinging from Theory: Autism and Opinions
- The Implications of Implanted Chips
- Anti-Smoking Campaign Doesn't Mess Around
- Meditation for Troubled Minds: Can the Mind Heal the Mind?
- Encephalon, Thirty-Third Edition
- Mind-Body: We Want Evidence, Don't We?
- Usually It's Cheaper to Pay Than to Go To Court
- God And Religion: Is It All In Our Heads?
- Integrating Schizophrenia Management
- Is War A Psychosis?
- Encephalon, Forthy-Third Edition
- Acknowledging Vaccination Concerns
- Staying the Course Prescribed for Major Depressive and Bipolar Disorders: A Family's Journey Thus Far
- Breaking News - Exercise is Good for You!
- Ethical Obligations of Health Care Workers During a Pandemic
- Treating Psychiatric Disorders - Something Smells Fishy
- Going Beyond Informed Consent
- Anti-Smoking Campaign Doesn’t Mess Around
- Vaccines - A Two-Edged Sword
- Prescriptive Authority - Are Pharmacists “Write”?
- Should Patients with Schizophrenia Receive Free Medication?
- Should Doctors Unionize?
- Blood Glucose and the Brain: Sugar and Short-Term Memory
- Should Doctors be Paid by Drug Companies for Research?
- How Do We Feed Our Children?
- Ethics 101 - Patients Who Hide The Truth
- Food Additives, Hyperactivity, and Common Sense
- Concierge Medicine - The Future or the Past?
- Brain Blogging, Thirty-Fifth Edition
- Are Placebos A Betrayal?
- New Technology for Intracranial Aneurysms
- Stem Cell Research - Man vs. God
- Using Infrared Light to Diagnosis Alzheimer’s
- Sorry - that last post was mine.
We have better medical care than they did in...
- What a great, informative article! I'm new to the blogging world, and found your...
- Thanks Toby, Yes, the numbers are frightening.
So it would be 39 million d...
- Starlight,
On the HHS webcast with teh OSHA folks they did admit that 68% ...
- GASP! Breaking news... Excuse me while I go lay down for a bit... whew
:D...
- Bless you starlight for your realistic math. The WHO numbers don't relate to re...
- I'm writing in RP, too. Once at Ivillage, (sorry, I've been signed in for awhile...
- My father passed away from bladder cancer caused by secondhand smoke. The 38,000...
- I agree about the necessity of DHA. However, DHA from fish is not ideal as it i...
- Since my vote is supposed to represent who I think would best serve my prioritie...
- Also, regarding the "Presidential Elect" (ughhh....) don't blame me - I was a RP...
- We have a lot in common. I pay "little attention" to GMF's (bad I know, but the...
- The WHO's numbers are not accurate.
There are approximately 6.5 Billion peopl...
- Thanks, Kobie.
I appreciate the heads-up regarding the upcoming event. I will d...
- Thanks for the article. Dept of Health and human services is having a webcast on...
- What benefits would a patient with schizophrenia have if they were to have a MRI...
- How ironic to address these issues on the anniversary of our "independence", as ...
- Hi,
I followed a conscious feeding regime with my eldest boy many years ago. ...
- LOL - I know too well of the revolving door of FDA/NIH and Pharma... if you real...
- Dr. Sherry Tenpenny's theory is that if mainstream medicine dares to question '...
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
Neuroscience & Neurology
June 26, 2008 | 4 Comments | By Jennifer Gibson, PharmD
Blood Glucose and the Brain: Sugar and Short-Term Memory
More In Neuroscience & Neurology
- New Technology for Intracranial Aneurysms
- Using Infrared Light to Diagnosis Alzheimer’s
- God And Religion: Is It All In Our Heads?
- Brain Prosthesis: Coming to a Hospital Near You?
- The Great Embryonic Stem Cell Debate
Neuroscience & Neurology
Opinion
July 05, 2008 | 2 Comments | By J. R. White
Breaking News - Exercise is Good for You!
More In Opinion
- Vaccines - A Two-Edged Sword
- How Do We Feed Our Children?
- Stem Cell Research - Man vs. God
- Only the Rich Get Old?
- Extremist Muslim Doctors Do More Than Heal
Opinion
Psychiatry & Psychology
July 03, 2008 | 2 Comments | By Jennifer Gibson, PharmD
Treating Psychiatric Disorders - Something Smells Fishy
More In Psychiatry & Psychology
- Should Patients with Schizophrenia Receive Free Medication?
- Does Having ADHD Mean Doing Poorly in School?
- Self-Medicating with Over-The-Counter Medicines for Mental Illness
- Interactive Effects of Genetics on Depression
- Postpartum Depression: Not Just For Moms















‘he himself, once upon a time was guilty of the same blame that he accuses others with’
Yes, I think he might realize that. Disagree, or no, please don’t assume he lacks introspection.